Reading Room · Last Chapter Coffee Blog

Coffee Old Fashioned Recipe

By Rogee Sirajeldin ·November 15, 2026

Coffee Old Fashioned Recipe

An old fashioned is the simplest serious cocktail there is — spirit, sugar, bitters, ice — which is exactly why coffee fits it so well. Coffee brings its own bitterness and roasted depth, so it can replace part of the sugar and all of the drink's wateriness at once. The result tastes like an old fashioned that grew up: darker, smoother, and with a long coffee finish that bourbon drinkers tend to love on the first sip.

Two Ways to Get the Coffee In

There are two schools, and they make noticeably different drinks. Coffee syrup — equal parts strong coffee and sugar, simmered until dissolved — keeps the drink spirit-forward and silky, closest to a classic old fashioned. Our homemade coffee syrups guide covers the base method. Cold brew concentrate makes a lighter, more coffee-forward drink with a little more dilution, better if you want the coffee to lead. Either way, use a bold, chocolate-leaning coffee: Whiskey Barrel Aged is almost cheating here, since its barrel notes were made for bourbon, and Mocha gives the syrup a natural cocoa undertone.

The Bourbon Coffee Old Fashioned

Ingredients: 2 ounces bourbon, 1/2 ounce coffee syrup (or 3/4 ounce cold brew concentrate plus 1 teaspoon simple syrup), 2 dashes aromatic bitters, 1 dash orange bitters if you have it, a wide strip of orange peel, one large ice cube.

  1. Add the bourbon, coffee syrup, and bitters to a mixing glass filled with ice.
  2. Stir for 20 to 30 seconds — stirring, not shaking, keeps the drink clear and silky and gives you exact control over dilution.
  3. Strain over a fresh large cube in a rocks glass. A big cube melts slowly, so the last sip tastes like the first.
  4. Express the orange peel over the glass — squeeze it so the oils spray the surface — rub the rim, and drop it in. The orange is not garnish for looks; its oils are what lift the coffee's heaviness.

The Zero-Proof Coffee Old Fashioned

Skip the bourbon and build it on cold brew alone: 3 ounces of cold brew concentrate, 1/2 ounce of coffee syrup or maple syrup, 2 dashes of bitters (note that most bitters contain trace alcohol — use a zero-proof bitters if that matters to you), stirred over ice and finished with the same orange peel. Made with Cold Brew Coffee, it has the body and bitterness of the original without the proof, and it holds up as an after-dinner drink in its own right. For more drinks in this family, our coffee and whiskey pairing guide covers why the two flavors work together, and the espresso martini recipe is the natural next step.

Where It Goes Wrong

Too sweet: Coffee syrups vary — start with 1/4 ounce and add. The drink should finish bitter, not candied. Cloudy or frothy: You shook it. Stir, always. Thin and watery: Your ice was small and wet, or the cold brew was regular strength instead of concentrate. Coffee tastes burnt: The syrup was made with over-extracted coffee; remake it with a fresh, smooth brew — bitterness from bad coffee and bitterness from bitters are not the same thing.

Batch tip for guests: multiply the bourbon version by four in a pitcher, stir it over ice to chill and dilute, and keep it in the fridge for up to a day. Add the orange peel per glass, never in the batch.

Dark, stirred, and unmistakably coffee — build yours tonight and use code WELCOME10 for 10% off your order.

Share: X Facebook Pinterest